VDAOvideo

The current state of on-chain governance with Meltem Demirors (Chief Strategy Officer of CoinShares)

TruStory · 166 views · 7 years ago
Description

We're going to talk about On-chain governance, it's a tendency to trend towards oligopolies, and what we can do to prevent that. Overall, On-chain governance is a messy topic and everyone seems to have different opinions about it. Some people wonder whether it even works or whether it's worth trying. On the other hand, some people feel it's the ultimate solution to problems of governance. There's a spectrum of views. And we're going to dive into each of these, talk about their merits, and maybe even plug in some data. We are joined by Meltem Demirors, Chief Strategy Officer of CoinShares, the digital asset manager, and a cryptocurrency investor, advisor, and advocate. She has a unique blend of experience in both legacy & blockchain-based finance and cryptocurrencies. Recently, Meltem wrote a blog post called "Power, Politics, and Protocols: Insights from On-chain Governance Data" where she analyzed the current state of On-chain governance. One of the main claims she made in the post was that the current mechanisms are trending towards oligopolies. We're going to dive into that today and get Meltem to elaborate on some of the ideas from her post. Time-stamps for the main points in our discussion: [01:57 What is governance? How has it been classically understood? And what does it mean to have On-chain governance? [02:53] Formal vs. informal governance, and their application to crypto, off-chain, and on-chain. [04:33] Using data available on voting outcomes in protocols to see trends in formal and informal governance. How on-chain governance differs when implementing changes in the protocol. [06:00 How the perceived "tyranny" of Bitcoin led to the creation of protocols with new types of governance. The block size wars happened in 2015 when Bitcoin was a $300 million network (it's $70 billion today.) [08:26] The benefit of open source software in dealing with disagreements on governance - you can just fork the code and create your own community with your own set of values. [09:37] Meltem's analysis of the governance mechanisms of Eos, Dash, NEO, Tezos, and Decred. [11:44] The two roles of staking: securing the network and participating in formal on-chain governance. [12:41] Participation rates in governance and how crypto matches up with real-world voter participation. What percentage of token holders are making the decisions? [15:10] Applying the Gini Coefficient to asset distribution. E.g. with Tezos, 80% of the tokens are held by 2% of token holders. The introduction of Crypto Plutarchies. [18:59] The ongoing decentralization debate: is it even necessary? [19:45] Whether or not on-chain formal governance is effective depends on the metrics you use for success. And these differ depending on the party, e.g. investors vs. end-users. [21:01] Why Preethi is the benevolent dictator of TruStory. [22:21] What happened when the Ethereum Dao got hacked: 5% participation on a vote over a hard fork. [25:04] Polybius on social organization, politics, and the structure of human society: people won't know what governance is unless they're educated about it. Is this participation accessible to most people? [27:16] The reason why we have representative democracies. 29:00] Meltem explains why centralization can be a good thing: incentivized experts acting in the best interests of all token holders. [30:33] Why a benevolent dictatorship is the most optimal form of governance for the vast majority of a populace. [34:52] Can the problems of governance be solved by applications that abstract out the complexity of participation? Asking the big question: "But why?" [39:20] Without critical thinking or healthy debate, we're living inside an echo chamber. Instead of becoming more insular, the crypto community should go out into the world and address the fundamental existential questions about crypto and blockchain networks. [41:43] How the fall of interest in religion leads to the rise of interest in science, truth, and reason, but also increasing fragmentation into self-selected communities and a lack of ability to have discourse. [42:39] Why staking will be a $1 billion industry by the end of 2019. [44:35] Crypto is a medium for permission-less financial innovation and it is silly that people are trying to play like the ethical or moral police for the industry. [46:29] For people to believe in Crypto, there has to be evidence Why we need better experiments to test hypothesis and more heretics who are willing to state unpleasant truths in the community. [48:05] The most important consideration for developers working on on-chain governance: Why is this necessary? [49:12] Blockchains don't change human nature. People have very different priorities and typically, people are the center of their own universe. If you're designing governance protocols, you need to understand humans and their behavior. If you liked what you saw and want exclusive access to the app, join today at beta.trustory.io