Consensus Is Not a Vote — Inside a Wikipedia Deletion Discussion
Description
Nine comments said keep, four said delete, and the article was deleted anyway. We unpack why Wikipedia's deletion discussions are explicitly not a vote, how a closing administrator weighs arguments against policy, and why a coordinated wave of new accounts counts as one voice, not many. Read the full note (in five languages): https://www.notabilias.com/en/journal/consensus-is-not-a-vote/ The Notabilias Podcast — daily field notes on what earns a place in the world's encyclopedia, with Adrian and Nora. From Notabilias, the independent English-Wikipedia consultancy. https://www.notabilias.com Written by the Notabilias editorial team; the voices of Adrian and Nora are AI-generated, so each note can reach you the same day it is written. Publication on Wikipedia is decided by its editorial
18:39How Consensus WorksAndrewism41.9K views
7:35Where to Map? for Community OpenStreetMap Projects – Jennifer Miller & John EllisOpenStreetMap US55 views
5:28How to apply consensus in communityFoundation for Intentional Community322 views
49:29Metagov Seminar - ARCH Voting Method Consensus-building Process (Schikowitz)Metagov71 views
25:17Equality in decision making for intentional communitiesRebecca Rachmany57 views
2:36Dean Spade: Basic Steps in Consensus Decision MakingBarnard Center for Research on Women4.4K views
2:49How to do consensus decision makingSeeds for Change44.3K views
43:11Consensus Bricolages -Flexible Voting Mechanism for Inclusive Urban Decision-makingCity Science MIT289 views
3:19Schumacher on Participatory DemocracySchumacher Center for New Economics4.1K views
3:57Fist to Five and Frodo: How to find consensusMIT ORSEL3K views
11:18Consensus or Sociocracy? What is best for your Intentional Community?Foundation for Intentional Community969 views
1:12:09The Purpose & Process of Consensus Decision-Making - AAANZ First Saturday, September 2024Anabaptist Association of Australia & New Zealand62 views
5:30Scenario 13: Building an Informed ConsensusMIT OpenCourseWare719 views
2:25Day 2 | Deliberative Democracy and Dispute ResolutionMIT OpenCourseWare1.9K views